Study

AI skips 9 in 10 Maps top 3 contractors

ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews named 10.6% of the Google Maps top 3 businesses (66 of 624) when we asked for the best plumbers, electricians, HVAC companies and roofers in the 20 largest US metros. 71.2% of the 208 AI answers (148) named none of the Maps top 3 for that city and trade.

We compared each answer with the Google Maps top 3 for the same city and trade. 624 is 208 answers times 3 Maps positions, so one business can count in more than one answer.

Key findings

10.6%

of the Google Maps top 3 were named in AI answers

66 of 624 top 3 positions across ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews.

3.9%

HVAC was named least

6 of 153 positions, against 16.0% for roofers.

39.6%

of listings with 1,000 or more reviews were named

Against 0.7% for listings with under 50 reviews.

82.5%

of the Maps top 3 were named by neither ChatGPT nor Gemini

198 of 240 positions.

  • ChatGPT named 12.1% of the Maps top 3 (29 of 240), Google AI Overviews 10.4% (15 of 144) and Gemini 9.2% (22 of 240).
  • Neither ChatGPT nor Gemini named 82.5% of the Maps top 3 (198 of 240).
  • HVAC was named least: 3.9% of its top 3 positions (6 of 153), against 16.0% for roofers, 13.2% for plumbers and 9.3% for electricians.
  • In checks where an AI answer named the listing, it had a median of 390.5 Google reviews. In checks where it did not, 25.
  • Listings with no website were named in 4 of 1,013 checks (0.4%). Listings with a website were named in 9.9%.
Bar chart. Share of Google Maps top 3 businesses named in AI answers: ChatGPT 12.1%, Gemini 9.2%, Google AI Overviews 10.4%, all three tools 10.6%.
Share of Google Maps top 3 businesses named in AI answers, by tool.

Near me searches and best-of questions

Google showed a local pack on 79 of 80 desktop "near me" searches (98.8%), one search per city and trade. It showed an AI Overview on 9 (11.2%). For the question "Who are the best plumbers in Dallas?" (with each trade and city changed), Google showed an AI Overview on 48 of 80 (60.0%), and ChatGPT and Gemini answered all 80. On those questions the AI answers named 10.6% of the Maps top 3.

Which trades get named

Share of the Maps top 3 named by AI answers, by trade
TradeAI answersMaps top 3 positionsNamedShare named
Roofers501502416.0%
Plumbers531592113.2%
Electricians54162159.3%
HVAC5115363.9%
All four trades2086246610.6%

Each trade rests on about 50 AI answers, so read the differences as direction. HVAC also has the most top 3 listings with no website: 32 of 60 (53.3%), against 23.3% for electricians, 13.3% for plumbers and 10.0% for roofers.

Bar chart. Share of Google Maps top 20 listings with no website link: plumbers 12.0%, electricians 31.2%, HVAC 41.8%, roofers 11.8%.
Share of Google Maps top 20 listings with no website link, by trade.

Who gets named

We checked every listing in every Maps top 20 against every AI answer for the same city and trade: 4,160 checks (208 answers times 20 listings).

Share of Maps top 20 listing checks named by AI answers, by Google review count
Google reviewsListing checksNamed by AIShare named
Under 502,427180.7%
50 to 1991,015797.8%
200 to 99950113326.5%
1,000 or more2178639.6%
Bar chart. Share of Google Maps top 20 listings named in AI answers by review count (4,160 checks): under 50 reviews 0.7%, 50 to 199 7.8%, 200 to 999 26.5%, 1,000 or more 39.6%.
Share of Google Maps top 20 listings named in AI answers, by review count.

Reviews and names go together in this data. The study cannot say whether reviews are the reason.

387 of 1,600 listings in the Maps top 20 (24.2%) show no website, and 60 of the 240 top 3 listings (25.0%).

Restricting to established listings (a website, at least 10 reviews and a name with more than trade and place words) leaves 134 of the 240 top 3 listings. AI answers named them 18.3% of the time (64 of 349 checks).

Among those established listings the share named is 22.2% for roofers (24 of 108 checks), 19.0% for electricians (15 of 79), 16.0% for plumbers (20 of 125) and 13.5% for HVAC (5 of 37). Only 15 of the 60 HVAC top 3 listings meet the test, against 48 of 60 plumbers, 29 of 60 electricians and 42 of 60 roofers, so part of HVAC's low rate comes from thin listings.

What the AI answers cite

The three tools cited 1,138 sources across the 208 answers. 45.7% (520) were directories and ranking sites such as Yelp, Angi, Thumbtack and "best of" lists. 12.0% (137) were business websites and booking pages, mostly sites of businesses in the Maps results we collected. Google's own pages made up 7.8%.

What a missed mention could cost in jobs

The study counted who gets named. It did not measure calls or jobs. The table uses two inputs: 100 homeowners a month ask an AI tool for your trade in your city, and 2 in 100 of them would book you if your name came up. Change both to your own numbers and the answer changes in proportion.

Formula: jobs missed per month = homeowners x booking rate x (1 minus the share of Maps top 3 listings in your trade that AI answers named).

Job value: a published price for a small job or repair in that trade, the low value, with sources below.

Jobs a missed AI mention could cost
TradeTop 3 named by AIJobs missed a monthJob value usedRevenue missed at that job value
Plumber13.2%1.74$150, bottom of the $150 to $500 range for a typical plumbing jobabout $260 a month
Electrician9.3%1.81$150, bottom of the $150 to $600 range for small to medium jobsabout $272 a month
HVAC3.9%1.92$350, average HVAC repairabout $673 a month
Roofer16.0%1.68$1,150, average roof repairabout $1,932 a month

Read the last column as arithmetic only.

Sources for job values:This Old House plumbing cost (updated 6 June 2026) andelectrician cost (updated 5 June 2026),Fixr HVAC repair cost (22 October 2026) andFixr roof repair cost (21 January 2026). Prices vary by city.

For comparison, 99 Callsreported Google Local Services Ads cost per lead for its US contractor clients in Q1 2026 (3,367 leads): electrical $35.70, plumbing $56.90, roofing $65.80 and HVAC $76.45. A paid lead and a customer who finds you in an AI answer are different things.

BrightLocal's 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey (1,002 US adults, published 11 February 2026) found that 45% use ChatGPT or other generative AI for local business recommendations, up from 6% a year earlier. The survey covers local businesses in general.

What this costs a contractor in fees is on the local SEO cost guide. For your own numbers, try the SEO cost calculator.

What a field service business can do

  1. Ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Google "Who are the best [trade] in [city]?" Write down which businesses appear and which sources each answer cites.
  2. Confirm your listing on each directory or ranking site the answers cite for your trade and city. Directories and ranking sites were the largest group of citations in this study.
  3. Put a website behind your Google profile, with a page for each service and area.
  4. Keep collecting real reviews. Named businesses had far more of them.

We do not know that any of these changes what an AI tool says, and one test gives one answer. Repeat the check each month and keep the results.

Trade by trade steps: electrician SEO,HVAC SEO and SEO for contractors.

More on how we run this work: SEO and AEO for field service businessesand SEO pricing.

We audit your site and your business, then deliver the findings within 1 to 2 days.

Method

Cities and trades. The 20 largest US metropolitan statistical areas by 2024 population estimate (US Census Bureau, Vintage 2024 estimates): New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Dallas, Houston, Miami, Washington, Atlanta, Philadelphia, Phoenix, Boston, Riverside, San Francisco, Detroit, Seattle, Minneapolis, Tampa, San Diego, Denver and Orlando. Four trades: plumbers, electricians, HVAC and roofers. That makes 80 city and trade pairs.

Google Maps. For each pair we searched Google Maps for the trade word ("plumber", "electrician", "hvac repair", "roofer") from one point in the city center, on mobile, at zoom 12, and recorded the first 20 listings: 1,600 listings. Sponsored style rows without a Google place ID (4) were left out. "Top 3" means the first three listings after that. We collected the Maps results for 71 pairs on 30 October 2026 and for 9 pairs (Chicago roofers, Dallas and Houston) on 31 October, through OpenSEO, which uses DataForSEO data. A listing with no review count is counted as 0 reviews.

AI answers. For each pair we asked ChatGPT and Gemini (their consumer sites) and Google (AI Overviews) one question: "Who are the best plumbers in New York, NY?" with the trade and city changed. One answer per question per tool, 30 October 2026, United States, English. ChatGPT and Gemini answered all 80. Google showed an AI Overview for 48. That gives 208 answered questions.

Counting a name. A Maps business counts as named when its name appears in the AI answer as a proper name. A script matched names to answer text: whole words only, a capital letter on the match, and trade and place words ignored when a name has other words in it. Names made only of trade and place words (224 of 1,600 listings, 14.0%) match only when the answer lists them as an item, so they may be undercounted. A second recount with separate code reproduced every headline figure from the raw files and read 40 answers (120 top 3 positions) one by one: no false matches and no missed matches. Our script and the recount disagreed on 9 of 4,160 checks, all below the top 3. We read those 9 answers and settled each by hand. Medians are taken over checks, so a listing named by three tools counts three times. We grouped cited sites ourselves using a domain list. The raw files stay internal. The dataset download holds counts and medians for each city and trade, with no business names.

What we left out. We also collected the organic Google results for the "near me" searches. The tool returned masked links for 862 of 1,141 organic rows, with titles that did not match the city, so we dropped the organic results. We counted only the local pack, AI Overview and ad features on those pages. We did not test Perplexity.

Limits. AI answers change from run to run and by user, so one answer per tool is a snapshot. Maps results change with the searcher's location, and we searched from one point per city. We counted names in answers, not clicks, calls or jobs. We cannot say why a business is named. "Best" questions are one kind of question, and homeowners ask others. In four of the 20 metros (Dallas, Houston, Seattle and Tampa) no AI answer named any of the Maps top 3. The Dallas and Houston Maps results were collected on 31 October, a day after the AI answers. We found no collection error, and each metro rests on 8 to 12 answers.

Cite this study

Pallidan (2026). AI answers vs Google Maps for US field service businesses.

https://pallidan.com/studies/field-service-ai-visibility/

<a href="https://pallidan.com/studies/field-service-ai-visibility/">Pallidan: AI answers vs Google Maps for US field service businesses (2026)</a>

Charts may be used with credit and a link to this page. Dataset: licensed CC BY 4.0, credit Pallidan with a link.Download the dataset (CSV, 80 rows). Every figure from this study in one table, with sources:AI search statistics for contractors.

Questions

How often do AI tools name the Google Maps top 3?

10.6% of the time in this study: 66 of 624 top 3 positions across answers from ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews.

Which trade is named least?

HVAC. AI answers named 3.9% of the HVAC Maps top 3 (6 of 153 positions).

Did the study measure calls or jobs?

No. It counted who gets named. The money figures on this page show what a missed mention could cost, worked from two inputs you can change.

Do reviews make an AI tool name a business?

The study cannot say. In checks where a listing was named it had a median of 390.5 reviews, and in checks where it was not, 25.

Book a free audit

Tell us what you sell and where you want to be in two years. If we are the wrong fit we will say so on the first call.

Get started